In the Spotlight: Paloma’s Award-Winning 2019 & 2021 Vintages

At Paloma, we farm carefully. We harvest thoughtfully. We ferment and barrel in small lots using only estate fruit. We release our wines when they’re ready—not when the calendar suggests we should.
And, over the years, the recognition has come. From leading publications to international competitions, respected voices have consistently found their way to our little corner of the Spring Mountain District.
The 2019 and 2021 vintages continue that story—earning praise not through flash, but through balance, structure, and authenticity.
Let’s begin where many wine lovers first discovered Paloma.
A Legacy of Recognition
In 2003, Paloma Vineyard’s 2001 Merlot was named Wine of the Year by Wine Spectator—selected from more than 15,000 wines worldwide. It was a defining moment, not because it changed how we made wine, but because it affirmed the quiet conviction we already held.
Since then, Paloma Merlot has appeared in the Wine Spectator Top 100 two more times, and our Cabernet Sauvignon has received Special Selection honors.
More recently, both Wine Advocate and international competitions have continued to recognize what we strive to do each season: allow the vineyard to speak clearly and honestly.
The 2019 and 2021 vintages carry that recognition forward.
The 2019 Vintage: Depth, Power, and Acclaim
The 2019 growing season began cool and wet, followed by a warm, moderate summer with few heat spikes. This resulted in a long hang time, allowing for optimal fruit development and the production of beautiful, high-quality, balanced wines.
2019 Merlot
85% Merlot | 15% Cabernet Sauvignon
33% New French Oak (Nadalié) | 14.8% Alcohol
1,792 cases produced
A dense ruby-purple in color, the 2019 Merlot reveals notes of strawberry jam intermixed with black cherries, oak, herbs, and a touch of chocolate. This is a medium-bodied offering that shows moderately tight tannins and a touch of sweetness up front. The wine will benefit from aeration and will pair beautifully with stuffed mushrooms and roasted pork loin.
“The Paloma Spring Mountain Merlot 2019 begins with a fragrant nose of boysenberry jam, black plums, anise, French lavender, violets, and sweet vanilla. The palate continues with blackberry compote, concentrated black currants, Kalamata olives, baker's chocolate, and licorice. This is a very dense, compact wine with amazingly concentrated, complex fruit interwoven with firm tannins that will allow it to age for well over a decade. As great as this wine is now, it will only improve over the next several years. I've enjoyed this wine over the decades, and this is the best vintage I can ever remember tasting.”
— Kevin M. Vogt, Master Sommelier, 95 Points
“Supple and generous, yet handsomely structured, with detailed red currant and cherry flavors highlighted by toasty spices and savory anise as this builds tension toward polished tannins.”
— Wine Spectator, 92 Points
96 Points — Frank Melis, Golden Gate Wines (“Top 25 Wines of 2024”)
The 2019 Merlot, with its balance of structure and fruit, is expected to reach peak expression at around 20 years—continuing Paloma’s long history of graceful aging.
2019 Cabernet Sauvignon
100% Cabernet Sauvignon
33% New French Oak | 14.8% Alcohol
462 cases produced
The 2019 Paloma Cabernet Sauvignon bursts out of the glass with waves of rich black and red fruits and a distinct note of cocoa in the background. This is a lush wine with a big mouthfeel, displaying beautiful purity of fruit. Consistent notes of dark cherry and plum combine with hints of black pepper and olive. The finish is long and silky. This wine will beautifully complement a hearty beef dish. Likely to evolve slowly, enjoy this beauty over many years.
The 2019 is 100% Cabernet Sauvignon, fermented and aged in French oak—33% new—for 18 months before being bottled in the spring and aged for an additional 30 months before release.
While the Merlot often draws the spotlight, the Cabernet continues to earn its own loyal following among critics and collectors who appreciate its layered structure and mountain intensity.

The 2021 Vintage: Resilience Recognized
If 2019 demonstrated precision, 2021 told a deeper story.
After losing our 2020 crop to smoke taint from the Glass Fire, seeing the vines return with strength felt like a quiet triumph. A cooler spring led to a hot summer and fall. Fruit ripened smoothly with decent hang time and looked excellent coming in at harvest.
Our winemaker described it simply: the weather held steady—no wild swings, no extremes—and that steadiness makes all the difference. When a season gives you that kind of consistency, the vineyard really does most of the work.
The wines carry that story—generous, balanced, and a reminder of what a good year can give.


2021 Merlot
85% Merlot | 15% Cabernet Sauvignon
33% New French Oak (Nadalié) | 14.8% Alcohol
1,708 cases produced
The 2021 Paloma Merlot opens quietly, with soft aromas of plum and cocoa. In the glass, it shows a clean, light red color. On the palate, it is smooth and approachable, with a medium body that carries notes of ripe fruit and subtle spice. Fine, peppery tannins add structure without overwhelming the wine’s natural balance. The finish is long and graceful, leaving a lasting impression of elegance and freshness.
“Rich and plush in texture, with generous, multilayered flavors of red currant and cherry laced with spicy cinnamon and mocha espresso. Finishes with polished tannins.”
— Tim Fish, Wine Spectator,
93 Points
“Exotic rose-like floral notes emerge on the nose, joined by hints of mint, cherry tomato and red berries. In the mouth, the wine shows the silky, well-rounded characteristics of ripe Merlot, plump and full-bodied, with a lingering, supple, mocha-tinged finish. Pricing is very reasonable for the quality and pedigree.”
— Joe Czerwinski, Wine Advocate,
94 Points
New York International Wine Competition — Double Gold, Best in Class — 95 Points
Peninsula Underground — Best Overall & Best Value — Selected as the Top Wine Overall in the Under the Radar California tasting series by Peninsula Underground. Recognition that highlights both quality and value aligns closely with our philosophy of fair pricing and mountain-grown excellence.
Like many Paloma vintages, the 2021 Merlot is built to age gracefully for 20 to 30 years, with peak expression expected around its twentieth year.
2021 Cabernet Sauvignon
100% Cabernet Sauvignon
33% New French Oak (Nadalié) | 14.8% Alcohol
343 cases produced
The 2021 Paloma Cabernet Sauvignon opens with bright cranberry and savory herbs, layered with notes of paprika and red chili flakes. A soft floral lift appears at the edge of the bouquet. On the palate, the wine delivers on its aromatic promise, with a peppery zip and a full-bodied mouthfeel. Firm tannins offer structure and suggest excellent aging potential. Flavors move from cool and vibrant up front to a warm, spicy finish that lingers at the back of the palate.
“There’s a lovely, savory sparkle to this version, which relies on red currant and bitter plum fruit for its core, while sage, bay and wet conifer accents are sprinkled liberally throughout. The sleek finish shows a subtle twang of iron. A pretty Cabernet.”
— Tim Fish, Wine Spectator,
93 Points
“Marked by hints of mint and pencil shavings, the nose also offers up attractive cherry and olive notes. It's a full-bodied but streamlined wine—especially when compared to the more zaftig Merlot—but it's still approachable, featuring ripe, silky-textured tannins and a long, softly dusty finish.”
— Joe Czerwinski, Wine Advocate,
93 Points
With only 343 cases produced, this Cabernet is both limited and cellar-worthy, expected to reach peak expression around 20 years.
2013 Merlot: A Vintage That Earned Its Place
There are certain years in Napa Valley that vintners speak about with a particular light in their eyes. 2013 is one of them.
Marked by warm, dry conditions and a long, unhurried harvest, the 2013 growing season in the Spring Mountain District allowed the fruit to ripen evenly and completely. The result was grapes with remarkable intensity, balanced acidity, and beautifully developed tannins—qualities that have made the vintage one of the most celebrated of the decade.
In the glass, our 2013 Merlot is immediately expressive. Raspberry and red plum rise first, followed by vanilla bean and dried red currant. With a little air, notes of fig jam deepen the aromatic profile. On the palate, it enters silky and round before revealing its structure at mid-palate—bright, acidic raspberry settling across the tongue, framed by fine, peppery tannins. The finish lingers with fresh raspberry and a pleasantly dry edge that quietly invites another sip.
Critics quickly recognized what we sensed early on.
Robert Parker of Wine Advocate awarded the wine 93 points, noting its “plum, black cherry and blackcurrant fruit, mocha and coffee bean in a lush, delicious and opulently textured style,” adding that it is “drinking beautifully already and will continue to evolve for another decade or more.”
Don Gillette of Napa Valley Wine Exchange placed the 2013 alongside our most iconic vintages—2001, 2007, and 2012—calling it a “fascinating beauty.” He praised its aromatic depth and mountain structure, describing a tapestry of dark berries, espresso, truffle, graphite, and spice woven together with firm, Cabernet-like tannins and a lingering, tightly wound finish.
Perhaps most exciting is its future. Paloma wines have long shown the ability to age gracefully for 20 to 30 years. With its balance of fruit, acidity, and structure, the 2013 Merlot is expected to reach peak expression around the 20-year mark. It is drinking beautifully now, yet still holds layers in reserve—an invitation to enjoy a bottle today and quietly tuck another away.
For those who have followed Paloma through the years, 2013 stands confidently in the lineage of our most celebrated vintages—proof of what thoughtful farming, a remarkable season, and patience in the cellar can achieve.
Recognition as Reflection
Awards matter—not as trophies, but as affirmation.
They remind us that careful farming, small-lot fermentation, thoughtful oak aging, and patience still resonate. They affirm that wines made with humility and consistency can stand confidently on a global stage.
The 2019 vintage showcases concentration and layered power.
The 2021 vintage reflects harmony, resilience, and renewal.
Together, they represent not just high scores, but a continued conversation between vineyard, vintage, and the wider wine world.
We are grateful for the recognition.
And even more grateful to share these bottles with you.















